Growing spending demands

The UK is set to enjoy a rare period of respite from Brexit related issues on 29 October when Philip Hammond delivers his third Budget. The Chancellor of the Exchequer may be in two minds about the fiscal position. In the near-term, borrowing has shrunk by more than expected this year.


Data for the first five months of 2018/19 suggest that the UK will record a deficit of £25-£30bn over this year, some 1.5% of GDP. Over the longer-term though, pressures on public expenditure are mounting. In common with other mature economies, adverse demographic trends imply that various categories of age related spending will rise over time.


Even more significantly, strains on the health budget are intensifying. In its recent assessment of fiscal sustainability, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) identified health spending as the single most significant drag on the public finances over the medium-term.


Given the uncertainty surrounding a final Brexit deal and the threat of a challenge to Mrs May, we view material tax increases, either on business or individuals, as politically challenging in this stage. While this should be a positive for business, we feel it is unlikely that there will be only limited boosts in the form of tax cuts this time round.


The Chancellor should however cut or at least extend the freeze on the £85,000 turnover threshold for VAT. Alongside the announcement that fuel duty will be frozen for a ninth year in a row, this constitutes a moderate fillip to the business environment.


Mrs May’s decision to increase NHS spending by £20.5bn combined with the Chancellor’s stated aim to balance the budget over the medium term continues to constrain any giveaways. Indeed, with the Brexit deadline fast approaching and many details of a deal yet to be negotiated, this Budget will likely be a “holding pattern” until further clarity emerges in March.


To this end, next year’s budget will have far more of an impact on business, though in what way remains tied almost exclusively to the final Brexit deal. Chancellor Philip Hammond is due to begin his speech at 3.30pm. Live updates to come. 

Download a pdf version of the economics note PDF 681.92 KB




Fiscal rules

This dichotomy is reflected in his fiscal rules. Overall Mr Hammond has said that he intends to balance the Budget during the next parliament. This pledge was made before last year’s ‘snap’ General Election and has not been updated since.


Hence the precise timescale to bring the public finances back in the black is unclear. At the time Mr Hammond made this commitment, the intention was for an election to be held in 2020 rather than 2017. Hence it is reasonable to suggest that he is aiming for 2025.


In addition to the Chancellor’s broad (and ambitious) objective, there are three detailed rules:

  • To reduce the structural deficit (cyclically adjusted PSNBx) below 2% of GDP by 2020-21. This is the ‘fiscal mandate’
  • That net debt (PSNDx) is falling as a percentage of GDP in 2020-21. This is the ‘supplementary target’
  • Welfare spending in 2022-23 is subject to a predetermined cap.
Philip Hammond
Philip Hammond, Chancellor of the Exchequer

The Chancellor originally stated he would balance the books ‘during the next parliament’. But this was said before last year's snap General Election.

Ahead of the OBR feeding in any policy measures at the upcoming Budget, these appear to be on track. At the time of the March Spring Statement, the OBR forecast that the structural deficit would be 1.3% of GDP in two years’ time. In other words the primary mandate would be met with a margin of 0.7% of GDP (or £15.4bn).


The OBR’s (non-adjusted) PSNBx forecast for this year in March was £37.1bn, which looks as if it could be undershot by £10bn or so. Strictly speaking we cannot say that this will represent an additional margin on the fiscal mandate – the target is cyclically adjusted and therefore also depends on the OBR’s judgements on factors such as spare capacity. But in broad terms, this year’s trends so far point in that direction.


Debt levels

On the second rule, the OBR’s March judgement envisaged that debt to GDP would fall marginally this year (i.e. two years early), following a modest increase in 2017/18.


Debt level last year, as a % of GDP

Latest official data at the time of writing (new figures for September were due on 19 October) show that debt was stable last year at 85.3% of GDP. With the trends in the public finances better than expected this year (we have long argued that the goal on supplementary debt is a quasi deficit target), the OBR seems likely this time to conclude that debt to GDP will be falling more materially in 2020/21 than it believed seven months ago.


The welfare cap was only reset a year or so ago. In March the OBR reported that, at this early stage, spending in 2022/23 (the point at which the rule is assessed), was on track to undershoot the £130.2bn cap by £1.5bn. It seems unlikely that much has changed at this stage.


Public finances

Decent data on the public finances so far this year partly reflects special factors, such as the timing of payments to the EU. But even abstracting from this we expect the deficit (PSNBx) to come down to £25bn-£30bn this year, a steady improvement over the past 3-4 years (see Chart 1).


This marks an impressive turnaround since the end of the financial crisis. In 2009/10 borrowing totalled £153bn, 9.9% of GDP. This year the total should come in below 1.5% of GDP. Outstanding debt remains high at close to 85% of GDP, which implies that the government should at least aim to contain borrowing over the medium-term. But Mr Hammond appears to face few problems in meeting his explicit fiscal rules.




Chart 1: Cumulative fiscal position across recent fiscal years (£bn)

Source: Macrobond



Will Mr Hammond still aim for a balanced Budget?

A much tougher constraint would be achieving a balanced budget. In its ‘Green Budget’ earlier this week, the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) pointed out that the government’s existing plans implied continued real terms spending cuts in non-protected departments.


But at the same time the PM has pledged that the UK is leaving austerity behind it. According to IFS calculations the government would require some £19bn to keep spending in these ‘unprotected’ areas steady. The government also faces immense pressure to provide additional funding to the NHS, relative to its current plans.


Indeed at the 70th anniversary of its creation, Mrs May announced that there would be a boost to health spending. The OBR’s estimates suggest that this is equivalent to an increase (in real terms) of £20.5bn by 2023/24.


There is a clear conflict between balancing the books and ending the squeeze on expenditure, at least without major tax increases.

Although the public finances appear to have improved more rapidly than expected at the time of the Spring Statement, there is a clear conflict between balancing the books and ending the squeeze on expenditure, at least without major tax increases.


Ending the squeeze on spending and delivering Mrs May’s health pledge (for example) would of course add significantly to the projected deficit which the OBR in March put at £21.4bn in 2022/23. There has been some talk about higher taxes being announced at the forthcoming Budget, but this would be politically toxic at this juncture.


Indeed in the near-term, we strongly suspect that the battle between the Chancellor’s economic policies and the PM’s political agenda is likely to be won by Mrs May. This is especially so given the uncertainties surrounding the Brexit process and that the Prime Minister may be susceptible to a challenge at some stage.



Chart 2: Impact of unfunded June 2018 NHS spending announcement (% of GDP)

Source: OBR Fiscal sustainability treport (July 2018)
Notes: The OBR has published its baseline projection for health spending over the next decade both with and without the additional funding pledged to the NHS. Based on the measures outlined at the Spring Statement, the OBR projected that health spending as a proportion of GDP would decline steadily through to 2022/23 before subsequently rising amid the demographic pressures outlined earlier. After factoring in the subsequent NHS announcement in June, however, the OBR now assumes it will rise throughout the full 10-year horizon without any offsetting tax or spending measures. This consequently sees it reach 8.3% of GDP in 2027/28, or almost a full percentage point higher than it otherwise would have been.




The impact of Brexit on the UK Budget

In terms of the economy itself, the OBR will publish an updated set of growth forecasts, underpinning its new fiscal projections and the upcoming Budget.


At this stage in the negotiations over the UK’s exit from the EU, with Brexit talks still very much up in the air, the OBR is not planning to base its economic assessments on any specific Brexit deal. Indeed, it has said for Budget 2018 there will be no significant changes to its “broad brush” Brexit assumptions.


In the midst of this Brexit uncertainty, we also suspect that forecast changes made at this round will be of the nature of adjustments to existing numbers, rather than a wholesale re-work.


Broadly, we would expect the other contours of the economic forecasts to hold up, albeit probably on a view that global growth this year and next will be slightly, but not materially, less robust, than envisaged back in March 2018 (forecasts were for 3.9% world GDP growth this year and next).


We suspect we will be faced with a modest downgrade to the 2018 UK GDP growth forecast (currently 1.5%) and perhaps a modest upgrade to the 2019 forecast (currently 1.3%). However we see little shift in the medium term UK growth positon, which currently envisages growth in a range of 1.3%-1.5% over the period to 2022.


Given that the jobless rate has continued to decline (to 4.0% currently), the OBR will almost certainly push down its end of 2018 forecast.

One area which the OBR might have had a bigger look at is its unemployment projections which, in March 2018, envisaged the unemployment rate closing the current year at 4.4% and then rising a little to 4.6% by the end of 2022.


Given that the jobless rate has continued to decline (to 4.0% currently), the OBR will almost certainly push down its end of 2018 forecast. Note though that again, much like with its GDP projections, it may be reluctant at this stage to make much bigger wholesale revisions, given the scope for the shape of the final Brexit deal to shift the balance of both the supply and demand for labour.


Broadly, we do not envisage the independent forecasting office making big enough changes to its economic forecasts, to shift the dial much on the fiscal backdrop. While the latter will be updated of course, this will principally be on account of any policy changes announced, plus ‘autonomous’ shifts (in this case the improvements discussed above) in the public finances.




Theresa May has given the Chancellor an expensive shopping list

Since the Spring Statement in March 2018, Prime Minister May has pointed to numerous medium-term fiscal giveaways and none of which look particularly cheap.


They include:

  • The Prime Minister’s June 2018 promise that the NHS budget will be expanded materially, with the OBR estimating her pledge would amount to a real terms increase in spending of £20.5bn by 2023/24.
  • The announcement that Fuel Duty will be frozen for the ninth year in a row. The freeze on fuel duty will cost £800m a year.
  • Prime Minister May’s renewal of her personal mission to fix the UK’s broken housing market in her speech at the Conservative Party conference this year, implying there may be further support on its way. Specifically here, we have already heard May’s pledge to raise councils’ borrowing cap (on how much councils could borrow against the value of their housing stock) so they are able to fund for housebuilding; an increase in council borrowing will lift the overall public sector net borrowing total, with the impact expected to be around £1bn a year.
  • The government’s Universal Credit scheme has come under increasing pressure of late, with a group of 27 Conservative MPs arguing that the welfare scheme needs an extra £2-3bn of cash to avoid leaving groups “significantly out of pocket”.




How does the Spending Review fit in?

The next Spending Review (SR 2019) is set to take place in 2019 and this will provide the Chancellor with the opportunity to review how it responds to the long term fiscal challenges facing the Exchequer.


It was envisaged at the time of the Spring Statement that the envelope for SR 2019 – i.e. the total envelope for spending over the period - would be published at the 2018 Budget (i.e. 29 October). This would outline the government’s spending commitments in aggregate and would therefore provide a template for the extent of tax increases that would be necessary to balance the books.


Would the government really want to do this at this stage? We guess probably not. Accordingly it is possible that the Chancellor will delay publishing the envelope. He could argue that it is sensible to do so until there is a clearer view of the final Brexit package and therefore the path the economy will take over the next few years.


Mr Hammond could instead commit to some increases in NHS cash over the short-term and announce that long-term decisions will be published at SR 2019. This would of course minimise disruption to the fiscal arithmetic without unveiling a major programme of tax increases and allow the Chancellor to look for some offsetting savings in other areas too.




What does it mean for my finances?

Assuming the Chancellor does shy away from publishing the envelope for SR 2019 and making long-term spending promises at the upcoming Budget, we suspect that any revenue-raising tax announcements in this Budget will not be of the biggest ticket type.


In this context, we note that the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) has looked at approaches which could increase tax revenues by around 1% of national income, enough to pay for the increase in NHS cash. They estimate that adding 1ppt to all income tax rates, or all self-employed NICs rates or the main rate of VAT would raise similar amounts of the order of £5.4bn to £6.2bn.


These would be material changes; lifting tax revenue by 1% of national income would “put the tax burden in the UK at around the highest level seen in the post-war era”, the IFS estimates. We do not see tax changes of this scale as politically feasible, at this stage.


As such, we suspect that the Chancellor will be looking at other smaller options to pick-up some cash, without worsening the political firestorm ahead of Brexit.


New fiscal measures

Here we note there has been talk of the following fiscal measures coming forward:

  • A cut to pension tax relief for high earners. Here it is being reported that Mr Hammond is either considering a reduction to the tax-free annual allowance or by reducing the rate of relief. Currently, annual allowances of £40k (tax free) are tapered downwards after earnings reach £150k. The talk is that this that could be lowered.

  • Recognising that it is easier to withhold than to withdraw a current benefit, there has also been some talk that the Chancellor might delay plans to raise income tax thresholds. Here the Conservative party’s manifesto pledge to raise the personal allowance (threshold for the 20p tax rate) to £12.5k by 2020 and the 40p rate threshold to £50k, could be vulnerable. However, no matter how desperate Mr Hammond is to raise some cash, we wonder if Prime Minister May will put the brakes on any such ideas, fearing a rebellion from within an already hostile Tory party. 

  • Other revenue raisers that the Chancellor might look to include a further shot at overhauling tax rules which allow self-employed people to avoid paying National Insurance Contributions, while it is quite possible that Mr Hammond will have another broad shot at closing tax loopholes. Indeed, loophole closing will probably be one of the revenue raisers the Chancellor can actually get away with without too much pushback from the PM.


If Brexit talks reach a positive outcome, a 2019 decision on the spending envelope might allow Mr Hammond to build in something of a boost.

While we expect to see some revenue raising initiatives announced on the 29 October, our assumption is that this will not be a Budget littered with tax rises and indeed some of the above changes could well be left in Mr Hammond’s back pocket.


If the Chancellor does opt to delay the publication of the Spending Review envelope that will allow him to look more comprehensively at how he funds new fiscal commitments such as the NHS and what tax adjustments (at next year’s Budget) are needed.


On top of this, if Brexit talks reach a positive outcome, a 2019 decision on the spending envelope might also allow Mr Hammond to build in something of a boost from this, if this leads the OBR to push up its economic projections.


This might further limit the scale of any revenue raising measures required and/or the need for Chancellor to admit defeat on his ambition to eliminate the deficit in the middle of the next decade.

Download a pdf version of the economics note PDF 681.92 KB

Discover how you can benefit from Investec's products and services

  • Disclaimer

    For the purposes of this disclaimer, “Investec Securities” shall mean: (i) Investec Bank plc (“IBP”); (ii) Investec Bank plc (Irish Branch); (iii) Investec Bank Limited (“IBL”); (iv) Investec Australia Limited (“IAL”); (v) Investec Capital Asia Limited (“ICAL”); (vi) Investec Capital Services (India)  rivate Limited; (vii) Investec Singapore Pte. Ltd (“ISPL”) and from time to time, in relation to any of the forgoing entities, the ultimate holding company of that entity, a subsidiary (or a subsidiary of a subsidiary) of that entity, a holding company of that entity or any other subsidiary of that holding company, and any affiliated entity of any such entities. “Investec Affiliates” shall mean any directors, officers, representatives, employees, advisers or agents of any part of Investec Securities. This document has been issued solely for general information and should not be considered as an offer or solicitation of an offer to sell, buy or subscribe to any securities or any derivative instrument or any other rights pertaining thereto. This document may have been issued to you by one entity within Investec Securities in the fulfilment of another Investec Securities entity’s agreement to do so. In doing so, the entity providing this document is in no way acting as agent of the entity with whom you have any such agreement and in no way is standing as principal or a party to that arrangement.


    The information in this document has been compiled by Investec Securities from sources believed to be reliable, but neither Investec Securities nor any Investec Affiliates accept liability for any loss arising from the use hereof or makes any representations as to its accuracy and completeness. Any opinions, forecasts or estimates herein constitute a judgement as at the date of this document. There can be no assurance that future results or events will be consistent with any such opinions, forecasts or estimates. Past performance should not be taken as an indication or guarantee of future performance, and no representation or warranty, express or implied is made regarding future performance. The information in this document and the document itself is subject to change without notice. This document as well as any other related documents or information may be incomplete, condensed and/or may not contain all material information concerning the subject of the research and/or its group companies (including subsidiaries): its accuracy cannot be guaranteed. There is no obligation of any kind on Investec Securities or any Investec Affiliates to update this document or any of the information, opinions, forecasts or estimates contained herein. Investec Securities (or its directors, officers or employees) may, to the extent permitted by law, act upon or use the information or opinions presented herein, or research or analysis on which they are based prior to the material being published. Investec Securities may have issued other documents or reports that are inconsistent with, and reach different conclusions from, the information presented in this document. Those reports and/or documents reflect the different assumptions, views and analytical methods of the analysts who prepared them. This document does not contain advice. Specifically, it does not take into account the objectives, financial situation or needs of any particular person. Investors should not do anything or forebear to do anything on the basis of this document. Before entering into any arrangement or transaction, investors must consider whether it is appropriate to do so based on their personal objectives, financial situation and needs and seek financial advice where needed. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is or will be made in relation to, and no responsibility or liability is or will be accepted by Investec Securities or any Investec Affiliates as to, or in relation to, the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of the contents of this document and each entity within Investec Securities (for itself and on behalf of all Investec Affiliates) hereby expressly disclaims any and all responsibility or liability for the accuracy, reliability and completeness of such information or this document generally.


    The distribution of this document in other jurisdictions may be prohibited by rules, regulations and/or laws of such jurisdiction. Any failure to comply with such restrictions may constitute a violation of United States securities laws or the laws of any such other jurisdiction. By accepting this document, you confirm that you are an "institutional investor" and agree to be bound by the foregoing limitations. This publication is confidential for the information of the addressee only and may not be reproduced in whole or in part, copies circulated, or disclosed to another party,  without the prior written consent of an entity within Investec Securities. In the event that you contact any representative of Investec Securities in connection with receipt of this document, including any analyst, you should be advised that this disclaimer applies to any conversation or correspondence that occurs as a result, which is also engaged in by Investec Securities and any relevant Investec Affiliate solely for the purposes of providing general information only. Any subsequent business you choose to transact shall be subject to the relevant terms thereof. We may monitor e-mail traffic data and the content of email. Calls may be monitored and recorded. Investec Securities does not allow the redistribution of this document to non-professional investors or persons outside the jurisdictions referred to above and Investec Securities cannot be held responsible in any way for third parties who effect such redistribution or recipients thereof. © 2018


    Third party research disclosures

    This report has been produced by a non-member affiliate of Investec Securities US (LLC) and is being distributed as third party research by Investec Securities (US) LLC in the United States. In the United States, this report is not intended for use by or distribution to entities that do not meet the definition of a Major US Institutional Investor, as defined under SEC Rule 15a-6, or an Institutional Investor, as defined under FINRA Rule 4512 (c), or for use by or distribution to any individuals who are citizens or residents of the United States. Investec Securities (US) LLC accepts responsibility for the issuance of this report when distributed in the United States to entities who meet the definition of a US Major Institutional Investor or an Institutional Investor

  • Investec Securities

    In the United Kingdom refers to Investec Securities a division of Investec Bank plc.
    Investec Bank plc is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority and is a member of the London Stock Exchange.

    Registered in England No. 489604

    Registered Office Address: 30 Gresham Street, London EC2V 7QP


    In Ireland refers to Investec Bank plc (Irish Branch) Investec Bank plc (Irish Branch) is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority in the United Kingdom and is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland for conduct of business rules.

    Registered in Ireland No. 904428
    Registered Office Address: The Harcourt Building, Harcourt Street, Dublin 2


    In South Africa refers to Investec Bank Limited an authorised financial services provider and a member of the JSE Limited.

    Registered in South Africa No. 1969/004763/06

    Registered Office Address: 100 Grayston Drive Sandown, Sandton 2196, South Africa


    In Australia refers to Investec Securities a division of Investec Australia Limited. Investec Australia Limited is authorised and regulated by the Australian Securities & Investments Commission (Licence Number 342737, ABN 77 140 381 184)

    Registered Office Address: Level 23, Chifley Tower, 2 Chifley Square, Sydney, NSW 2000


    In Hong Kong refers to Investec Capital Asia Limited a Securities and Futures Commission licensed
    corporation (Central Entity Number AFT069). Registered Office Address: Suite 3609, 36/F, Two International Finance Centre 8 Finance Street, Central Hong Kong


    In India refers to Investec Capital Services (India) Private Limited which is registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India, the Capital Market regulator in India as a research analyst,

    Registration number INH000000263.

    Registered Office Address: Unit no 607, 6th floor The Capital, Plot no C-70, GBlock, Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra East, Mumbai 400051

    In Singapore refers to Investec Singapore Pte. Ltd. an exempt financial adviser which is regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore as a capital markets services licence holder.

    Registration No. 201634931E

    Registered Office Address: 80 Raffles Place #36-09, UOB Plaza, Singapore 048624


    In the United States refers to Investec Securities (US) LLC.
    Registered Office Address: 10 East 53rd Street, 22nd Floor New York, NY 10022


    Further details of Investec office locations, including postal addresses and telephone/fax contact details: