Skip to main content
Investec Women's Summit for Institutions 2026 panel discussing capital and conviction

Capital and conviction | South Africa’s capital deployment challenge

South Africa has capital and an urgent need for investment. The challenge is turning that capital into productive assets with credible plans, appropriate returns and risks that investors can accept.

Investec has a balance sheet it wants to deploy. Prescient Investment Management wants to invest more in infrastructure and clean energy. Yet many of the projects it considers do not make it through the investment committee.

That gap gets to the heart of South Africa’s capital deployment challenge.

The country needs investment in infrastructure, institutions have long-term capital but need alone does not make a project investable.

“From a bank point of view, we’re open for business, we’ve got a balance sheet and we want to deploy” said Melissa Bilsland, co-head of Investec for Institutions. “We see fierce competition in the market for high-quality corporate assets.”

Investors are looking for opportunities; the test is whether those opportunities offer a return that justifies the risk.

That question shaped the Capital & Conviction panel at Alpha Redefined, Investec’s inaugural Women’s Summit for Institutions, held in Cape Town.

Melissa Bilsland
Melissa Bilsland, Co-head of Investec for Institutions and Head of Institutional Finance, Investec

We see fierce competition in the market for high-quality corporate assets.

What makes a project investable?

For Cheree Dyers, chief executive officer of Prescient Investment Management, the starting point is responsibility to the people whose money the industry manages.

“The reality is you’re looking after people’s savings,” she said.

A project must therefore pass practical tests and investors must then understand how the project will earn an income. “Who will pay? If we deploy capital, we need to get income back from that,” said Dyers.

Renewable energy shows why those questions matter. A wind or solar project may be ready to build but unable to connect to the grid. Technical readiness does not automatically make it an investable asset.

The return must also compensate the investor for taking the risk. Infrastructure may be essential to economic growth, but an asset manager cannot commit pension savings simply because the underlying need is compelling.

Government needs a clearer playbook

Investability also depends on what happens around the project.

Nonhlanhla Peggy-Sue Khumalo, head of public sector stakeholder engagement and strategic partnerships at Investec, said capital has been cautious about political change and policy uncertainty.

“Capital allocation depends on whether opportunities really meet the requirements of the investors or the pension funds and asset managers i.e. reliable power, efficient logistics, functional ports, water security, digital connectivity and transport infrastructure,” she said. “However, risk is not confined to what happens when we invest. There is also risk in what happens when we do not. Underinvestment can contribute to deteriorating infrastructure, weaker productivity, constrained business expansion, lost employment opportunities and reduced competitiveness.”

Policy continuity is part of that judgement. “Investors need to understand not only what the policy is, but rather whether it will endure,” Khumalo said.

Khumalo argued for a clearer pipeline of infrastructure projects that identifies where private capital can participate and how. She pointed to the renewable energy procurement model as an example of how predictable processes can give investors greater certainty.

Nonhlanhla Peggy-Sue Khumalo
Nonhlanhla Peggy-Sue Khumalo, Head of Public Sector Stakeholder Engagement, Investec

Capital allocation depends on whether opportunities really meet the requirements of the investors or the pension funds and asset managers.

Not all capital carries the same risk

Making projects investable is only part of the problem, the source of funding matters too. “There are other pockets of money where we are willing to take a little bit more risk, and we need to mobilise those and allocate appropriately” she said.

A bank may need a credible path to repayment over five years while a pension fund can invest over a much longer period, but it still needs liquidity to meet retirements and redemptions. The underlying asset does not become liquid simply because an investment structure allows investors to redeem some of their capital.

Risk also changes as a project develops. Funding an asset during construction is different from buying an established asset in the secondary market. That creates scope for institutional investors to build infrastructure exposure across different stages rather than treating the sector as a single investment.

Private markets can widen the opportunity set further. Natalie Phillips, deputy managing director of Ninety One’s South African business, said they can give investors access to parts of the economy that are poorly represented in listed markets. She cited data centres as one example.

But more assets do not automatically mean more diversification. “Don’t end up with a portfolio that you think is diversified and it’s actually ultimately concentrated,” Phillips said.

Natalie Phillips
Natalie Phillips, Deputy Managing Director, Ninety One

Don’t end up with a portfolio that you think is diversified and it’s actually ultimately concentrated.

Conviction needs evidence

Better projects and clearer policy can make it easier to commit capital, but they cannot remove uncertainty nor should investors expect them to. “Waiting to allocate capital is an active decision,” Dyers said.

There is an important difference between patience and paralysis. Patience gives investors time to gather information that could change a decision, paralysis waits for certainty.

The more useful question is what could go wrong and how much capital an investor is prepared to put at risk if it does. That also means being prepared to change course when the evidence changes.

The cost of caution belongs in the calculation too. Waiting can protect capital when important facts remain unclear. But delay can also mean missing an opportunity or investing too little in an asset that will be needed in future.

South Africa’s problem is not solved by telling institutional investors to invest more. Their responsibility is to allocate capital where the evidence supports the risk.

Government and project sponsors have a corresponding responsibility; they need to give capital something it can assess like clear policy, credible projects, predictable processes and a route to sustainable returns.

“Put up what actually works, put up what the project is delivering, and put up what those investment returns are,” said Dyers.

Cheree Dyers
Cheree Dyers, Chief Executive Officer, Prescient Investment Management

Waiting to allocate capital is an active decision.

An opportunity that still needs discipline

The case for deploying capital in South Africa does not rest only on infrastructure need.

Phillips argued that South Africa’s investment prospects should be considered against global conditions and the country’s longer-term fundamentals.

“I think the noise needs to be separated from what the long-term fundamentals look like. We really do believe that for South Africa, this is the start of a very exciting positive phase from an investment point of view and that the investment case for SA remains very attractive and we think this is the start of it,” she said.

That provides an important counterpoint to the reasons capital remains cautious that the opportunity may be improving before every constraint has disappeared.

2026 Women’s Summit for Institutions

Get more insights from Investec

Previous
Previous