The PM lost the second meaningful vote on her Brexit deal in the House of Commons on Tuesday evening by a margin of 391 to 242, a defeat of 149. A number of Mrs May’s own Conservative MPs voted against her, mainly members of the ‘eurosceptic’ European Research Group (ERG).
They were joined by the 10 MPs from the Northern Irish DUP, which props up the government. The overall numbers compare a little more favourably with the calamitous margin of 230 in January, but events nonetheless represent a categorical rejection of the deal which leaves the nature of the UK’s future relationship with the EU very unclear.
This is despite a frenetic end to the negotiations between the UK and the EU. These resulted in a new compromise on the Irish backstop, the contentious proposal which, if other arrangements failed, would maintain an open border between the North and the Republic. Attorney General Geoffrey Cox’s judgement was that under the terms, the UK would have no unilateral right to leave the backstop, an unchanged assessment.
However he also stated that the new agreement would reduce the risk that the UK would be ‘involuntarily detained’ there. It could be argued that if both the EU and the UK were both striving towards a free trade deal, there would be few reasons to leave the backstop and arguably the restrictions are relatively minor. But that now seems by the by.
What next for Brexit?
The important questions now are what happens over the rest of the week and the broader direction of the Brexit debate. The first has been set out, while the second is highly uncertain.
After the vote the PM indicated that the House will vote on both whether to leave the EU without a deal and if not, on whether to ask the EU for an Article 50 extension. The first vote (which will be a ‘free’ vote) will take place on Wednesday, and if appropriate, the second on Thursday. It is virtually inevitable that with the Commons in deadlock, Parliament now needs an extension to Britain’s membership to prevent it crashing out of the EU without a deal on 29 March.
Extending Article 50
Indeed we would expect the Commons to ask to extend the Article 50 period. All of the other 27 EU countries need to approve this, and after the vote EU Council President Donald Tusk insisted that such a request need to be reasoned, with credible justification.
The EU's chief negotiator last night stepped up preparations for a "no-deal", saying that it was now up to the UK to solve the impasse.
Despite all this, we judge that the UK will be granted an additional three months, if it asks for this. As we have written previously, a longer delay to exiting would pose problems with elections to the European Parliament (EP) in late-May, bearing in mind that the new EP is set to convene on 2 July.
We will probably know more on the EU’s appetite for an extension during next week’s Summit on Thursday and Friday.
However it is not clear how the UK would use this time to resolve matters. The PM might decide to try and press on with a new version of the existing deal. But the EU appears to have moved as far as it is going to on the backstop.
Meaningful vote 3?
So winning ‘meaningful vote 3’ would probably require a sudden change of mind among a large number of Tory dissenters (overturning a defeat of 149 is a tough ask). Another option could come from the Conservative backbenches in the shape of MP Nick Boles’s plans to stay in a customs union with the EU as well as the European Single Market (European Economic Area or EEA).
This idea may get airtime in parliament but there are no indications that it could gain sufficient cross party support. In summary, we would like to make the following points:
- There does not seem to be any specific proposal which can gain the confidence of the House. Unless various groups of MPs become more willing to compromise it is difficult to map out a way forward. In the current climate, this looks unlikely.
- One outcome that a majority of MPs seem to oppose is ‘no deal’. Although not impossible, we still consider the possibility of leaving the EU without a deal to be relatively small. Sterling rallied modestly immediately after the vote, but quickly fell back again. The currency appears to be anticipating a vote against ‘no deal’ tomorrow. For the latest rates, click here.
- There are now more rumblings about a second referendum or a general election. At the current juncture we would tend to rule nothing out. However unless the government loses a vote of no confidence (which would require the loss of support from the DUP), an election looks very unlikely (we cannot see Mrs May going to the polls again).
- Furthermore the government has always been and still is, strongly opposed to another referendum.
What now for Theresa May?
A frequent question over the course of this week is whether the PM, now having lost the second meaningful vote, will now stand down. We doubt this. In any case it is not clear what it would achieve, save opening up a new Conservative leadership contest at the point where the country requires a period of political stability.
Perhaps the only way that Parliament will back a specific deal is when MPs recognise that their favoured option is a non-runner and that the alternative is even more unpalatable. However it is not clear what that route is.
How did sterling react to Theresa May's defeat?
How did sterling react to Theresa May's defeat?
Manage your currency exposure
Get the latest on currency markets, direct from the dealing and trading desks
Complete our simple form to receive our daily morning email and stay up to date with issues that affect your business.
Browse articles in