Another meaningful defeat for May
13 March 2019
Prime Minister's EU withdrawal deal rejected by a margin of 149 votes, throwing her Brexit strategy into further confusion.
5 min read
Tuesday 12 November
07:30
Sterling was firmer yesterday after Brexit Party leader Nigel Farage announced that his party would not contest the 317 seats won by the Conservative Party in 2017 in the upcoming December election. Although the Brexit Party had pushed for a “Leave alliance” with the Conservatives, such efforts look to have petered out.
Mr Farage announced that he had taken the decision “unilaterally” after judging the Prime Minister had recently signalled a "big shift of position" in his approach to Brexit, citing the Boris Johnson’s pledge not to extend the transition period and the renegotiated Political Declaration as examples.
Note also that Mr Farage has not ruled out making further concessions; after being asked whether this was his final offer, the Brexit Party leader replied “I haven’t even considered that at this moment in time. I’ve just taken 48 hours to make this decision. Allow this one to settle first”.
However, the deadline for candidates to submit their nomination forms is Thursday, so Mr Farage will have to decide quickly if he is to shift his position further. But though UK risk sentiment was supported amid signs that the Conservatives would have a less obstructed run in the upcoming general election, the Brexit Party is still planning on taking on Labour-held constituencies.
This may well split the ‘Leave’ vote in target seats that Mr Johnson is aiming to capture in his bid to win a parliamentary majority. Note also that this is in addition to the other challenges that the Conservatives face, including being squeezed by the SNP in Scotland and the Liberal Democrats in Southern England.
With just over four weeks to go under the general election, we cannot say with conviction that the Conservatives will gain a large or even small majority.
Wednesday 30 October
07:30
Last night the House of Commons voted overwhelmingly by 438 to 20 for a General Election on 12 December. This was the result of the government’s "one-line" bill and followed its failed attempt to call an election using the Fixed-term Parliaments Act on Monday evening.
This time Jeremy Corbyn and a majority of Labour MPs backed an election. As this will be an Act of Parliament, it requires consideration by the House of Lords today, but it is thought that the Lords will not try to obstruct or amend the bill. Royal Assent is then expected by Friday and Parliament will be dissolved next week. In terms of opinion polling, the Tories have gained in recent weeks and on average are leading Labour by 12-13 per cent.
However, the party is under pressure in London, the south-east, the south-west and Scotland and needs to win seats from Labour in the Midlands and the North to gain an overall majority. Note that PM Johnson restored the party whip to 10 of the 21 rebel MPs who were expelled a few weeks ago.
Tuesday 29 October
07:30
Last night, Prime Minister Boris Johnson failed in his third attempt to secure an early election under the Fixed-Term Parliaments Act (FTPA). His push for an election on 12 December was defeated 299 to 70, falling well short of the 434 (i.e. ⅔ of all 650 MPs) needed under the Act to trigger an election, with the Labour party abstaining.
But Mr Johnson is set to try again today to bring about an election on 12 December, albeit through the use of a one-line bill which would circumvent the FTPA by only requiring a simple majority to pass. He has previously been hesitant to go down this route as such a bill would be amendable. Note also that House of Commons Leader Jacob Rees-Mogg confirmed last night that the government will not bring back its Withdrawal Agreement Bill (WAB).
Crucially, this satisfies a key demand of the Liberal Democrats and the SNP who are pushing for an alternative polling day of 9 December in the belief this would allow more students to vote in their university towns. It is unclear at this stage whether the Liberal Democrats and/or the SNP will be willing to back the bill, having insisted that the pledge to not re-introduce the WAB be copper-bottomed.
But the Financial Times reports this morning that Downing Street officials admit that the government will probably have to compromise on the date of the election and that a “landing zone” between 9 and 12 December could be found.
Monday 28 October
07:30
The EU27 is close to granting the UK a third Brexit extension to 31 January, having reached the conclusion last week that Westminster cannot pass the negotiated deal before this Thursday (31 October).
An official announcement from Brussels in that respect is expected this morning. PM Boris Johnson plans to pass a motion this evening to call an election for 12 December, but under the Fixed-term Parliaments Act he needs a two thirds majority of MPs to back him, a total of 434. Mr Johnson has tried (and failed) this route twice already and success this time looks similarly unlikely.
An alternative is that a Lib Dem/SNP inspired motion for an election on 9 December is allowed tomorrow, which would only require a simple majority, therefore not requiring the bulk of Labour MPs to vote in favour. Number 10 Downing Street has dismissed this a ‘gimmick’ but reports suggest that it is being taken seriously by the Government. Note that the Prime Minister’s push for a December election has seen the 6 November Budget postponed.
Thursday 24 October
07:30
EU ambassadors are still currently debating whether to grant a Brexit extension, though it is highly unlikely they won’t. French President Emmanuel Macron is understood to be pushing for a minimal extension of just two weeks, with the view that anything longer could undo the progress that has been made over the last fortnight.
While others, such as German Chancellor Angela Merkel and European Council President Donald Tusk, are looking to grant the full extension as per the UK request, to 31 January. This might potentially come with a clause such that, should the deal be ratified prior to this date, the UK could leave the EU before the deadline. Donald Tusk is expected to make the announcement tomorrow if an agreement has been reached, if not then the European Council may meet on Monday to force a decision.
If the extension to 31 January is granted, Prime Minister Boris Johnson is likely to push for a General Election in late November, with opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn also now coming to the view Labour will have to back an election motion once a suitable extension is granted, though with many in Labour also said to be opposed to this.
There is speculation that Johnson could make a third attempt at triggering an election as early as today. What is confirmed for today however, is the vote on the government’s agenda that was laid out in the Queen’s Speech, expected around 17:00 in the House of Commons.
Wednesday 23 October
7:30
Prime Minister (PM) Boris Johnson won the important “second reading” vote on the Withdrawal Agreement Bill (329-299). The result that shows Parliament now has a majority of MPs in favour of the PM’s Brexit deal.
However the joy for the PM was soon wiped away as the subsequent “programme motion” vote was defeated by 322 votes to 308, showing Parliament objecting to Mr Johnson’s plans to rush the legislation through Parliament with only limited time for debate.
Frustrated with this, the PM has now said he will “pause the legislation” whilst he waits to see how the EU responds to the extension request on the Brexit date, which was submitted to the EU at the weekend. EU Council President Donald Tusk tweeted last night that he has recommended that the EU27 accept the UK’s extension request, but it is the length of any extension request that will be critical in determining what the PM’s next move will be.
It is not clear that even a fungible extension which would set out a period to 31 January, but allow an earlier exit after appropriate ratifications, would be enough to dissuade him from pushing for an imminent General Election – with Johnson seeming to favour just a 10-day extension, at most.
As we have said many times, the Fixed-term Parliaments Act does add hurdles to the triggering of a General Election and opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn might instead favour a renegotiation of the Withdrawal Agreement Bill timetable, rather than handing Mr Johnson an election on his timetable. All that said, the prospect a near term election remain probable, with a December vote still in focus, though we note also that there is continued talk of a Spring 2020 poll too.
Tuesday 22 October
7:30
Today the Withdrawal Agreement Bill (WAB) will get its ‘second reading’ in the House of Commons, after the Bill was introduced last night. Reports indicate that no.10 is quietly confident of winning the second reading vote. If the vote is won, the Bill will then be progressed into the Commons Committee stage, where more controversy will come into the mix.
In Committee stage, various amendments (such as on a confirmatory referendum being attached or a requirement to compel the PM to negotiate a customs union future arrangement) will be proposed and potentially voted on. After committee stages, the Bill will go to third reading, currently touted for Thursday night and even after that the Lords then needs to go through the same stages and the Commons consider any amendments passed by the Lords.
In short, there is quite a road to travel before the Bill sees its way into law, with the current Brexit date just over a week away. With the second reading vote seemingly set to pass, the most critical vote today looks set to be on the 'programme motion' which will determine the parliamentary timetable for the Bill. If the government’s timetable proposal is defeated, then it is unlikely the Bill will pass the necessary stages in time for an EU exit on 31 October.
The EU will then likely respond to the UK’s extension request, faced with a much clearer prospect of the UK being unable to complete the necessary processes ahead of the deadline. This will further heighten speculation of a near-term General Election, as PM Johnson eyes a route to getting a clearer mandate to pass his Brexit deal. In terms of timing for today, the second reading vote is expected about 7pm, with the Programme Motion vote immediately after.
Monday 21 October
16:00
No meaningful vote four (MV4) today: Speaker of the House of Commons John Bercow has ruled out a fourth meaningful vote happening in Parliament today. As such the next step will be the presentation of the Withdrawal and Implementation Bill which will go for debate (2nd reading) in the House of Commons from tomorrow.
As such it now looks as if Parliament’s agreement, or not, with Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal with be tested in subsequent votes on this legislation. Given the scope for such discussions to get side-tracked with various amendments (particularly on a confirmatory referendum being attached and on customs union proposals), it may therefore take longer for the will of Parliament to be known.
In the meantime, expect Brussels to slowly mull over the UK’s Brexit extension request that was delivered on Saturday. Sterling is little changed after the news, after an initial dip, now at $1.2994.
Monday 21 October
07.30
Saturday's special sitting of Parliament, designed to help Johnson get Brexit over the line by 31 Oct, has in fact provided further delay. No 'meaningful vote' was held in the House, thanks to an amendment to the Benn Act from Oliver Letwin.
This subsequently required the Prime Minister to send a letter to the EU requesting an extension, though he did not sign it. Thus far there has been no official response from the EU, though Donald Tusk confirmed receipt of the letter and said he would begin discussions with European leaders. With 'no-deal' at seemingly lower risk still, despite the delay, sterling is holding up at $1.2909 currently.
For today, the key focus will be on whether Mr Johnson's government gets another shot at holding a fourth meaningful vote and on the "programme motion" which, whilst sounding overly technical, would importantly clear the pace for the legislation to be discussed and progressed. On both fronts, there looks to be scope for the PM's plans to get tied up in opposition amendments and objections.
For more detailed acquaintance of the weekend's developments, see yesterday's note: Extension rebellion raises Brexit uncertainty.
Friday 18 October
07.30
Last night the EU Council formally endorsed the deal agreed between the UK and EU and it is now left to the UK government to get it approved in the fourth meaningful vote (MV4) in Parliament tomorrow (Saturday). It is not clear how the numbers stack up.
MV3 was defeated by 58 votes, so a net 30 MPs is required for MV4 to pass through. Importantly the 10 DUP MPs are currently set to vote against it, though the government will no doubt be under discussions to offer it some sweeteners in exchange for their support. A number of the 28 Tory ERG MPs that voted against MV3 have suggested they will back the government tomorrow, although there is a danger that Conservatives that previously backed a deal will now vote against it.
Boris Johnson will no doubt be persuading various Labour MPs to back it – 5 fell in behind MV3 in March. We suspect, but cannot be confident, that MV4 will be approved tomorrow.
For analysis of yesterday’s Brexit deal, please see our note Brexit white smoke, but will Parliament blow it away?
Thursday 17 October
10.45
News from Brussels this morning confirms that a deal between the UK and the EU has been reached over the UK’s exit from the European Union. This has been confirmed by both PM Boris Johnson and Jean Claude Juncker, who has stated that he will recommend that the European Council endorse the agreement later this afternoon.
In all likelihood this will mean that the government will put the deal to the House of Commons this Saturday for a vote. The full details of the arrangement are yet to be made public and the DUP’s exact position remains somewhat unclear given some reports that they are on board with the deal and others that they still have reservations.
Sterling has risen strongly, now trading at $1.2940 against the US dollar and 85.9p (€1.1627) against the euro.
Thursday 17 October
07.30
Brexit negotiations continued throughout the course of yesterday and reportedly reached an advanced stage with all but one of the outstanding issue having supposedly been resolved. Today’s papers suggest that the single remaining issue remains how VAT will be treated in Northern Ireland under the revised Irish protocol, with the latest proposals reportedly based on it remaining in the EU's VAT area.
But the Prime Minister has been delivered a blow this morning after the government’s confidence and supply partners the DUP signalled it “could not support what is being suggested on customs and consent issues”. Uncertainty over whether the deal will pass a ‘meaningful vote’ in the House of Commons has seen the pound fall sharply this morning, with cable dropping 60 pips to $1.2757 on the news.
Looking ahead to the two-day European Council Summit which kicks off today, the Prime Minister is scheduled to arrive in Brussels shortly before 2:00pm. In focus today will be whether negotiators are able to overcome the final hurdles to present a legal Brexit withdrawal text today and if the DUP can be persuaded to support the deal in a possible meaningful vote on Saturday.
Wednesday 16 October
07.30
Brexit talks are set to resume later today after they ran into the early hours of the morning as negotiators race against the clock to produce a draft legal text of an agreement for the European Council Summit (17-18 October). Reports overnight suggest the two sides are close to reaching an accord, but one that hinges on whether the UK will accept a customs border in the Irish Sea while keeping Northern Ireland inside the UK’s customs union.
Crucially, this will be dependent upon whether this can be supported by the DUP (the government’s confidence and supply partners) as well as the eurosceptic ERG in any ‘meaningful vote’ given that the two have previously voiced opposition to an Irish Sea customs border.
In an effort to win them over, the Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, held meetings with the DUP and the ERG at Downing Street yesterday evening. Following these talks, head of the ERG Steve Baker concluded “I am optimistic it is possible to reach a tolerable deal that I am able to vote for” but the DUP still appear unconvinced after stating that “gaps remain”.
Looking ahead, a key moment today will be EU Chief Negotiator Michel Barnier’s briefing to EU ambassadors, which is expected at around 1:00 pm London time. Beyond this, Mr Johnson will convene his Cabinet around 4:00pm before then speaking to the 1922 Committee of backbench Tory MPs around 7:30pm.
Markets have reacted positively to signs that an agreement is within touching distance, with sterling now trading at around $1.2790, the highest since May this year.
Tuesday 15 October
07.30
There has been an absence of concrete news from negotiations in Brussels over the past 24 hours and more talk of the gaps to be closed if there is to be any hope of a deal, ahead of the EU Summit later this week (17-18 October). Indeed, the Finnish PM Antti Rinne (with Finland holding the EU Presidency currently) said explicitly last night that “more time” was needed.
As such there is continued talk of a further last-minute Summit being arranged to discuss Brexit on 29-30 October, while the focus of the Brexit talks later this week is said to be on the shape of any extension. Domestically, Boris Johnson has postponed today’s Cabinet
meeting to give negotiators another day before they have to report back to his top team.
Today Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay is set to make an unscheduled visit to Luxembourg to see European affairs ministers at the General Affairs Council. This morning, we await comments from Brussels' chief negotiator Michel Barnier who will update EU27 ministers and speak to the press afterwards.
Monday 14 October
07.30
After the optimism over a possible Brexit deal at the end of last week, the mood this morning is more hesitant ahead of the 17-18 October EU Summit. After intensive talks over the weekend, Brussels is still puzzled over the UK’s customs proposals, which would see Northern Ireland stand in a UK customs territory with goods charged appropriate tariffs, depending on whether they head into the Republic of Ireland or not.
EU negotiators are confused over how this would work and concerned that the model would leave the bloc vulnerable to fraud, in the absence of a hard border. As such, it appears that are quite sizeable differences still to be narrowed if a deal is to be struck at the Summit later this week. Talks will continue today, but there is also discussion of an additional Summit taking place 29-30 October to give a bit more time for a deal to be reached.
Additionally, questions remain over whether, if a deal is struck, Mr Johnson can secure the passage of this through UK Parliament, given more euro-sceptic Tory MPs have been less comfortable with the direction of movement of proposals over recent days.
Today marks the State of Opening of Parliament as the government presents its legislative program, with debate set to follow on this, most likely next week. Also of note will be Parliament’s special sitting on Saturday (19 October). Here Parliament will either be discussing a deal, if there is one, if not debating other options including other options, including the extension which is mandated to occur from that point, under the Benn Act.
Friday 11 October
07.30
Prime Minister Boris Johnson met with the Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar for Brexit talks yesterday at Thornton Manor in Merseyside. After two hours of discussion, the two leaders “agreed that they could see a pathway to a possible deal”.
Mr Varadkar went on to describe the talks as “very positive and very promising”, adding that a new Brexit agreement was “possible” by the end of the month. So far no detail has emerged about what movement was made by either side, but the positive readout of the talks has served to reassure investors that a deal is not as elusive as previously thought. Sterling has surged on the back of the news; it has gained over two cents against the US dollar to currently trade at $1.2448, while versus the euro it has strengthened from 90p to 88.5p.
Focus will now turn to a meeting between Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay and EU Chief Negotiator Michel Barnier today in Brussels which is set to commence at 8:00am London time and expected to last around 90 minutes. Talks are set to centre on the understanding reached between Mr Johnson and Mr Varadkar yesterday and will determine whether the EU believes they can form the basis of a deepening of the negotiations.
But despite the recent positive progress, we still judge it would be a herculean task to renegotiate a deal with Brussels in time for next week’s European Council Summit (17-18 October) to avoid the need to ask the EU for a third Article 50 extension on 19 October.
Thursday 10 October
07.30
Boris Johnson and Leo Varadkar meet face to face today in an attempt to break the impasse on a new deal. This may prove to be a tad ambitious. The EU27 has not responded positively to the UK’s proposals last week, objecting to the specific mechanism whereby NI gives ongoing consent to the arrangements and more importantly, to the UK’s plan whereby NI forms part of the UK’s customs territory, necessitating a customs border on the island of Ireland.
There is talk of a counterproposal from the ‘27’ whereby the UK enters a customs arrangement similar to that of Spain and the Canary Islands. However this would involve a customs border along the Irish Sea and is likely to be rejected by Westminster. Unless something dramatic happens soon, an accord will remain out
of sight this week and the UK will request a third extension on the 19th, or very soon after. Indeed it was announced yesterday that parliament would sit on 19 October, the first Saturday session in the Commons since 1982.
Separately Jeremy Corbyn is reported to be defying a large number of his MPs by pressuring them to back an election, if and when an extension is granted by the EU. On that subject, the PM assured the ‘One Nation Group’ Tory of MPs that he would not be fighting a general election on a platform of ‘no deal’.
Wednesday 9 October
07.30
Yesterday the mood over a possible Brexit deal ahead of the EU Summit (17-18 Oct) took on a notably more downbeat tone, with various UK and EU officials suggesting that negotiations were reaching a dead end.
This at least partly seems to be driven by a frosty call between PM Boris Johnson and German Chancellor Angela Merkel. Time remains, but it looks likely that the talks that David Frost had been undertaking in Brussels this week will not be continued today.
Meanwhile, a meeting between Boris Johnson and Leo Varadkar later this week (Thursday or Friday) looks to be a last-ditch attempt to reach a deal. But the general feeling is that these will be unfruitful, given the position Dublin has taken over the UK’s latest proposals.
It has even been suggested that Boris Johnson may not even attend the EU Summit should an agreement not be reached. The result has been a number of accusations traded between the UK and the EU over the blame for the lack of progress. In the absence of any reversal in fortunes and an agreement being reached between the UK and the EU, it is looking increasingly likely that the Prime Minister will be forced into requesting an extension to the 31 October Brexit date (as mandated by the Benn Act).
Despite this legal assurance, a deal is seemingly further away than ever before and it is impossible to rule out a disorderly departure. Read our concise guide to find out how prepared Britain and the EU are for a no-deal Brexit, and discover what you need to do and how you can mitigate the risks.
Should the UK enter into another extension, a general election, possibly in mid-December, looks an increasingly likely outcome. Certainly there is already an air of an election in Westminster, with reports this morning suggesting that there are some differences in opinion over the party’s Brexit stance within any Conservative Party manifesto, with up to 50 Tory MPs unwilling to support any manifesto which pledged to pursue a no-deal Brexit.
The market reaction to the latest Brexit developments has been a renewed weakness in sterling, with GBP:USD just about holding onto the $1.22 level this morning.
Tuesday 1 October
07.30
The week will see the government put forward its formal proposals on how it plans to address the renegotiation of Brexit. Reports suggest this will be on Thursday following the end of the Conservative Party Conference tomorrow.
While will still don’t know the full detail, the outline of the government’s proposal to replace the so-called backstop centres on an ‘all-Ireland’ special economic zone for food and agricultural products. This would effectively see the necessary regulatory checks being carried out at “customs clearance sites” away from the border in the Republic of Ireland and rely heavily on technology to track and trace shipments, in a proposal that sounds remarkably similar to the Theresa May’s maximum facilitation plan.
According to the Financial Times the proposal also reportedly contains a transition period that runs until 2022 in order for the technology to be implemented. To date the plans only appear to cover agricultural and food products but there have been some suggestions that the plans could be widened out to manufactured goods as well, but that would be dependent on the consent on Stormont when it reconvenes.
However what we don’t yet know, is how the government plans to deal with customs arrangements, an area where the DUP is resolutely opposing any idea that would see customs checks being imposed across the Irish Sea. Ultimately how these Brexit proposal are received in the EU this week could be crucial in determining the likelihood of the UK reaching an agreement with the EU at the 17-18 October EU Summit.
Tuesday 24 September
11.00
Today the Supreme Court ruled that the Prime Minister’s prorogation of Parliament was unlawful after having concluded that it was indeed a matter for the courts. In a statement explaining the decision, Lady Brenda Hale argued that it was “not a normal suspension of Parliament” and that no reasonable justification had been put forward by the government.
It ruled that the prorogation should be quashed but that it would be for the speakers of Parliament to decide on what steps to take. Note that House of Commons Speaker John Bercow has already said that MPs should “convene without delay”.
Meanwhile, Prime Minister Boris Johnson is currently in New York but we should hear his response around midday when he is set to attend a televised breakfast event.
Market sentiment has been bolstered by the ruling with sterling climbing sharply to $1.2486 in the immediate aftermath. Though it has since pared its gains to now trade at $1.2448, it is still 0.2% up on the day.
Monday 16 September
07.30
The past weekend has been yet another busy one for Brexit news. One major focus has been talk of Boris Johnson defying the legislation which would force him to ask for an extension rather than accept no-deal, from 19 October.
Here PM Johnson’s parallel with the Hulk grabbed many headlines as he said “the madder Hulk gets, the stronger Hulk gets”. However, despite this talk there is more speculation that Mr Johnson is working towards a deal and looking at proposals to replace the backstop mechanism.
The PM is in Luxembourg today meeting European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, with other key advisers. Aside from the press that went to former PM David Cameron’s memoirs, the defection of Tory MP Sam Gyimah to the Liberal Democrats served as a reminder that Mr Johnson’s headache over divisions in his party are not over.
The Liberal Democrat party conference at the weekend confirmed speculation that the party would now move forward on a platform of campaigning for a revocation of Article 50. Coming up we have the Labour party conference over the coming weekend and into next week.
Finally, the Supreme Court is set to rule tomorrow on the legality of the decision to prorogue Parliament, which is now suspended until 14 October. Depending on the ruling, this could lead to Parliament being recalled and potentially then a second prorogation, kicking off another political storm.
At its current standing, sterling is holding onto gains from the perception that no-deal risks look to have lessened after the passage of the recent legislation and that a deal might be within reach. Indeed, cable is at $1.2475 this morning.
Friday 13 September
07.30
Various reports suggest that the DUP is softening some of its red lines on the Irish backstop. In particular, the party is said to be considering accepting an alignment with EU rules on animal and agricultural products, providing that NI institutions are able to scrutinise EU legislation.
It is not clear how far the DUP is willing to shift its position on other goods. And of course, the thorny issue of customs checks will need to be addressed. But the direction of travel is positive and there is a related rise in sterling, which is currently trading a little above $1.24 and at 89.4p against the euro.
Tuesday 10 September
07.30
Prime Minister Boris Johnson lost his second attempt at triggering an early General Election yesterday after he failed to achieve the backing of 434 MPs (two-thirds of the 650 MPs), as required under the Fixed-term Parliaments Act.
Many Labour MPs abstained in the vote as expected, with only 293 votes, mainly Conservative, in favour of the early poll. In other unhelpful developments for the Prime Minister MPs passed a motion requiring Mr Johnson to hand over emails and call records related to no-deal Brexit planning and over the suspension of Parliament.
The prorogation came into effect in the early hours of this morning, with the Brexit extension legislation (to avoid no-deal on 31 October) having become law on Monday. MPs will now break from Westminster until October where the Queen’s Speech will mark the opening of a new Parliamentary session on 14 October.
Between now and then PM Johnson will be considering his options that could help him stick to his ‘do or die’ pledge to leave the EU on 31 October. Options said to be under consideration including
None of the above look to be straightforward or even perhaps possible legally. For now though we may get a period of quiet as the PM considers his options and in the build up to party conference season.
Monday 9 September
07.30
After a chaotic week in Parliament, Brexit is set to dominate the political scene this week as well, particularly given that Parliament will be suspended (prorogued) until 14 October some time between today and Thursday. After last week’s fast tracking of the opposition/Tory rebel bill to extend Article 50 by 3 months, it is set to receive Royal Assent today.
There were some question marks over whether the government would take an unprecedented line and ignore the law, particularly in light of Boris’s comments that he would ‘rather die in a ditch’ than request an extension. But the reports this morning suggests that the government may toe the line and abide by the law.
A further consequence of the extension bill passing for Royal Assent is that the government is set to table another general election motion today. However as with last week’s election attempt, that looks set to fail.
In terms of the rest of the political calendar for today Boris Johnson will be visiting Irish Prime Minister Leo Varadkar in Dublin, it is unlikely that there will be much progress on the Irish ‘backstop’ issue, with Mr Varadkar being quoted over the weekend saying that he did not expect any breakthrough.
Lastly, the bad news continued for the Prime Minister over the weekend, with Amber Rudd announcing her resignation. That followed Boris’s brother Jo Johnson’s resignation on Friday, leaving the government now 45 short of a majority, which is an untenable situation in the long term.
Wednesday 4 September
07.30
Boris Johnson’s defeat in Parliament last night means that anti no-dealers will take control of the order paper today and seek to legislate for a three-month extension to avoid a no-deal Brexit, if no deal is reached before 31 October.
A total of 21 backbench Conservative MPs crossed the aisle to defy the government, including Father of the House Ken Clarke, former Chancellor Philip Hammond and Winston Churchill's grandson Sir Nicholas Soames. All 21 have now been stripped of the Tory whip and will sit as independents in the House of Commons.
Mr Johnson’s government has now tabled a motion for an early General Election, unhappy that he considers his hands are now to be tied in Brexit negotiations by legislation which takes no-deal off the table. However, while Labour has been keen to see a General Election, there are doubts whether Labour will back the General Election motion today as they seek to tie Mr Johnson’s hands with the anti no-deal legislation first.
The challenge for the anti no-dealers is to get the legislation passed as quickly as possible, before Parliament is dissolved next week. Meanwhile there are some signs that steps are being taken by those who favour keeping no-deal on the table, to delay and therefore attempt to prevent the Bill receiving Royal Assent before Parliament is dissolved.
Indeed, there are reports of 92 amendments having been proposed to the Bill for its House of Lords consideration. In terms of timings, it is likely that the debate in the Commons will happen from 3pm onwards, with a vote on second reading penned in for around 5pm and with the item in its entirety listed on the order paper as running to 7pm.
In terms of the Early Parliamentary General Election motion, 90 minutes has been allocated for this. This is being slated to happen around 9pm. Finally note that just before 1pm Sajid Javid delivers his first spending review, setting out 2020/21 budgets for Whitehall departments.
Tuesday 3 September
22:15
Boris Johnson’s government has been defeated in Parliament tonight by a vote of 328-301. This means that anti no-dealers will take control of the order paper tomorrow to debate and legislate to seek a 3-month extension to avoid a no-deal Brexit.
PM Johnson has said he is now tabling a motion for a General Election, unhappy that he considers his hands are now to be tied in Brexit negotiations by legislation which takes no-deal off the table. It is likely that the anti no-deal legislation would get the required support in the Commons, but there are questions over whether it can pass in time before Parliament is dissolved, given discussion also about a ‘filibuster’ attempt in the House of Lords being used as a tactic to try to delay its progress.
As for the General Election, whether this motion passes depends on whether Labour backs the vote, given a two-thirds majority is required. Labour has been committed to seeking a General Election, but is wary of PM Johnson’s tactics here. Indeed, in the immediate aftermath of the vote result the Labour Leader Jeremy Corbyn indicated that he would support a General Election, but only once legislation blocking a no-deal Brexit had been passed.
Tuesday 3 September
07:40
Prime Minister Boris Johnson spoke outside 10 Downing Street last night and warned that moves to block a no-deal Brexit would “plainly chop the legs out from under the UK position”. He went on to say “I don’t want an election, you don’t want an election”, but briefing to the media overnight suggests that Mr Johnson will call a ‘snap’ general election on 14 October if MPs successfully push through legislation to tie his hands.
Under the Fixed-term Parliaments Act (2011), Mr Johnson would have to lay down a motion “that there shall be an early parliamentary general election” and would then need two-thirds of MPs to vote in favour of it. It would, therefore, require the support of Labour MPs, but given comments by Leader Jeremy Corbyn it is not thought that the party will be an obstacle even though the Conservatives lead by around 10 points in recent polls.
Moves to block a no-deal Brexit would “plainly chop the legs out from under the UK position”.
Prime Minister Boris Johnson
In the meantime, attention will turn to the House of Commons where opposition parties and rebel MPs plan to apply for an emergency debate under Standing Order 24 in an effort to push through legislation that would prevent the Prime Minister from pursuing a no-deal Brexit without the consent of Parliament. The European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 6) Bill, as it is called, would require the Government to either a) reach a deal with the EU, or b) gain Parliament's approval for a no-deal Brexit.
If neither of these conditions are met by 19 October, then the government would be obligated to request a three-month Article 50 extension (i.e. until 31 January 2020). If Brussels agrees to this extension, then the Government must immediately accept, but if it proposes a Brexit delay to an alternative date then it must be accepted within two days unless it is rejected by the House of Commons. Parliament is set to reconvene around 3:30pm today and we expect the petition to be made to the House of Commons Speaker John Bercow around 6:30pm today with the vote (if accepted) to be held around 10:00pm.
Crucially, the plan would require Mr Bercow to accept the debate, but he is expected to do so after having labelled Mr Johnson’s lengthy five-week prorogation of Parliament a “constitutional outrage”. With speculation that the Bill has sufficient support, cable has slipped below $1.20 for the first time since 2017 this morning as investors eye the elevated risk of a general election which could see a hung parliament given that the Brexit party would be expected to split the eurosceptic vote with the Conservatives.
Wednesday 28 August
17:00
The Queen today formaly approved a request by the government to prorogue Parliament (i.e. terminate the current parliamentary session). This had been threatened earlier in the summer in the context of preventing the House of Commons from meeting, in order to neutralise the risk of MPs blocking a ‘no deal’ Brexit.
It is not clear what the precise motivations are, however we note that there were stories overnight suggesting that Leader of the House Jacob Rees-Mogg was struggling to get enough MPs to back a three week recess over the party conference season, as is customary practice. The suspension will begin a few days after MPs return to work in September, and reopen with the Queen’s speech taking place on 14 October.
It should be noted that the conference recess is typically just over three weeks and that the final major party conference (Conservative) ends on 2 October. Hence the parliamentary break is longer than usual and, although pro-Brexit MPs contest the reasons behind its length, it is probably designed to limit parliamentary time to introduce legislation to force the government to negotiate a further extension to the Brexit date (currently 31 October).
Sterling fell sharply, slipping back more than a cent against the dollar from today’s highs to $1.2171, although it recovered later in the day, back to 1.2249 by 5pm.
Wednesday 14 August
07:30
The Speaker of the House of Commons John Bercow has said he would not allow PM Johnson to close Parliament to push through Brexit. Note though that no-deal Brexit does nevertheless remain the default option, whether Parliament is open or not.
On the subject of suspending Parliament, there was also the first court outing yesterday to try and limit this, with Scotland’s highest civil court set to hear a bid by about 70 lawmakers to try stop PM Johnson suspending Parliament to force through Brexit.
The other big theme of the past 24-hours is election planning, after one Conservative politician accidentally published a draft email about his “GE2019 team.” Indeed with each day that passes, there are increasing signs that PM Johnson and his team are prepping to go to the polls over the next few months, although this is not hugely surprising given that with a majority of just 1 currently (with the DUP) the Johnson government is going to find the passage of legislation a very tall order.
Monday 29 July
07:30
Growing fears of a no-deal Brexit have seen sterling weaken further over the weekend, with the pound now trading at just $1.2367 against the USD.
Sentiment has been dampened after Michael Gove said that the government is now “working on the assumption” that the UK will leave the EU without a deal on 31 October. Note that today he will chair today’s inaugural Brexit ‘war Cabinet’ (aka. XS) in the Prime Ministers absence.
The XS, or the ‘exit strategy committee’ to give it its formal name, is a group of six senior Cabinet ministers who will meet twice-weekly on Mondays and Thursdays to take crucial Brexit decisions. All the while, a number of rebel MPs have sounded demoralised since the appointment of Boris Johnson as Prime Minister.
This morning Reuters reports that Sir Oliver Letwin MP has warned that “we have to accept that we may find ourselves leaving without a deal”.
Tuesday 16 July
12:30
Sterling is under particular pressure today after overnight news added to worries that the UK might be headed for a no-deal Brexit. The first source of concerns came as both Tory leadership candidates (Boris Johnson and Jeremy Hunt) indicated that they thought the Irish backstop was dead, raising difficult questions over the direction either candidates could move in, to secure a deal with Brussels and one which could pass Parliament.
Secondly, no-deal concerns have been heightened by reports of yesterday’s meeting between EU Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier and UK Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay. The trip was “to keep channels open,” but Barclay was said to be working to prepare the ground for his new boss’s arrival in Downing Street. The meeting was said to be a stormy one as Barclay told Barnier that the withdrawal agreement was dead, not once but five times.
Against the euro, the pound is now languishing at lows last seen in January (currently 90.3p) whilst it stands at $1.2425 against the USD, having touched a low of $1.2408 just before midday, a low last seen in April 2017.
After the first round results in the Tory leadership contest the field of candidates has been narrowed down to 7, with Leadsom (11), Harper (10) and McVey (9) all failing to make the cut. Rory Stewart also came close to being eliminated surpassing the 17 vote threshold by two.
Of the results the most notable figure is the 114 vote total for Boris Johnson, which puts him way out in front of his nearest rival Jeremy Hunt who received 43 votes. Michael Gove came in third with 37 votes. Read our anaysis how the result of the Tory leadership election could affect foreign exchange rates.
The key point to take from this, is that if Boris manages to maintain his backers he is going to be hard to beat. The next round of voting takes place on Tuesday 18 June.
Labour lost its bid to prevent a no-deal brexit after an opposition day motion was defeated by 309 votes to 298. If the vote had passed it wouldhave given MPs the chance to table legislation to prevent a no-deal Brexit on 31 October 2019.
Ten Tory rebels voted against the government by backing the motion, but eight eurosceptic Labour MPs voted against it.
It is being reported that today Labour will initiate a cross party effort to try and reduce the scope for a new Conservative party leader to deliver a ‘no-deal’ Brexit. This comes amid assertions, particularly from former Brexit Secretary Dominic Raab, that a no-deal Brexit could be achieved by simply failing to bring Brexit back to the Commons, including with talk of proroguing (suspending) Parliament to help achieve this.
Channels for Parliament to take control of the Brexit process are more limited now, with the Withdrawal Agreement Bill having not been taken to Parliament it is now not possible for amendments to be attached to such legislation to alter the course of events. As such Labour appears to be looking at using today’s opposition day debate, to attempt to gain control of the parliamentary agenda on 25 June.
Labour is expected to be backed by the likes of the Liberal Democrats and the SNP, plus some others, to seek measures including legislation, to help avoid a no-deal Brexit, while also preventing a future PM from proroguing Parliament to force Brexit through. Parliament has on balance been opposed to no-deal Brexit, so any action to avert no deal could pass the Commons.
Note though that a Bill brought by Labour’s Yvette Copper in April, seeking an extension to avoid no-deal, passed by just one vote. For sterling, positive steps that reduce the prospect of no-deal would likely provide a key footing to the pound, where nervousness over heightened no-deal Brexit risks amid the Tory leadership race have weighed on the currency of the late.
GDP figures for the month of April were weaker than expected with output falling 0.4% month on month - market consensus and our view had been for a 0.1% monthly fall.
Part of the reason for April’s weakness was a 24% mom fall in car output which was related to planned shutdowns in the sector, which in turn were linked to Brexit.
As a result manufacturing output was much weaker than expected with a 3.9% mom fall (consensus -1.4%, Investec -2.2%), as was the broader estimate of industrial production which witnessed a -2.7% fall (consensus -1.0%, Investec -1.5%).
Following Theresa May’s resignation statement on Friday (she will stay on until 7 June and then act as caretaker PM until a successor is chosen), the Conservatives are reeling from Thursday’s European elections.
They came fifth behind the Green Party, with a 9% share of the vote, their worst performance in the past 200 years. The Brexit Party topped the vote with 32%. This has upped the ante on the government to leave the EU on 31 October, with a number of candidates to replace May (at the latest count there are 10 of them) stating the need to depart on that date, with or without a deal.
Just to highlight the degree of political pressure on the Tories, The next scheduled major political event takes place in the shape of the parliamentary by-election in Peterborough on 6 June to replace the disgraced Labour MP Fiona Onasanya. The Brexit Party is odds on favourite to capture the seat.
Unsurprisingly, in the face of further political uncertainty and increased chance of a hard Brexit on Halloween, GBP didn’t manage to gather any support yesterday in markets and remains vulnerable.
There is a notion that GBP is becoming a bit long in the tooth for all this political malarkey and to an extent it has built a strong immune system to the Brexit seesaw but comments over the weekend from our peers in markets have raised the possibility of GBPUSD trading to 1.1000 in a no-deal scenario.
The dust needs to settle and the Tory leadership race now needs to play out for us to have greater clarity of the outlook for GBP but what is for sure is that rallies will be restrained in both GBP/USD and GBP/EUR until there is a hint of consensus on new leadership and alignment on a Brexit deal.
As widely anticipated Theresa May just delivered a statement outside No 10 Downing street, stating that she will formally resign as Tory leader and the Prime Minister on 7 June.
She will however remain in place in the meantime until a new leader is Tory leader is selected. Sterling has edged lower on the news to $1.2672 (GBP:USD), having initially jumped above $1.27. Full note to follow shortly.
Yesterday saw a rush of speculation as to whether Prime Minister May was going to step down voluntarily or be forced out. In the end she stood fast, refusing to meet various cabinet ministers.
These developments followed PM May’s ‘bold new offer’ earlier in the week, which included a 10-point plan to try and entice Labour support for the Withdrawal Agreement Bill (WAB). However the inclusion of the a Commons vote on a second referendum galvanised opposition within the Tory Party and even within the Cabinet, where Leader of the House Andrea Leadsom resigned last night.
It would now appear that PM May’s remaining time is very limited, perhaps just days, although she will not go today given the European Parliamentary elections, as political coverage is restricted.
There has been some talk that she may go by the end of the weekend, but at this point it is simply not clear. It should be worth noting that the executive committee of the 1922 Committee of backbench MPs met last night, where it refrained from altering the leadership rules to allow an immediate confidence vote in the PM.
The committee has however reportedly agreed in principle a change to the rules by mid-June should PM May have not stood down by then. Despite the great deal of uncertainty over the Prime Minister, the broad points we would make are that;
Yesterday the Prime Minister delivered what she called a "bold, new Brexit offer", in a last-ditch attempt to secure support for her deal. In it she outlined a 10-point proposal of items that would be included in the Withdrawal Agreement Bill (WAB).
This included points such as:
PM May will deliver a statement to the House of Commons today, with the Bill reportedly set for a Commons vote in the week commencing 3 June, potentially on the 4th or 5th.
The points included in yesterday’s offer appeared to be a gamble by the Prime Minister to try and entice Labour support in trying to pass the WAB and on the hope that the vote on a second referendum failed to pass given that in the last indicative vote, it lost by 292 votes to 280.
However given the tone of reports overnight it would seem that PM May's gamble is almost certain to fail.
For one, the inclusion of a Commons vote on a second referendum has alienated many Tories, including some of those who supported her plan at the third meaningful vote. A meeting of around 40 ERG Tory MPs last night unanimously agreed to oppose PM May's plan.
Second, the response from Labour MPs has been less than glowing, suggesting that PM May’s plan has had little traction with the opposition. The arithmetic, if anything now looks more challenging and we would judge that the WAB will probably lose by a greater margin than in the third meaningful vote (on the Withdrawal Agreement only), which failed to pass by 58 votes.
This looks to be the last roll of the dice for the PM, who is set to meet the 1922 Committee Chair Sir Graham Brady after the vote to set out a path for her departure.
This will likely trigger a leadership contest over the summer, with a new Tory party leader and therefore new Prime Minister installed at the Tory party conference in September.
Sterling has remained weak on the continued Brexit uncertainty breaking through $1.27 to $1.2696 this morning.
Brexit developments over the weekend have seen Prime Minister May promise a ‘bold new’ Brexit offer, in one final push to break the deadlock over Brexit. The government might even bring the Withdrawal Agreement Bill (WAB) to parliament next week, with talk of a vote on either the 4th or 5th June.
The details of this offer are reportedly set to be agreed at tomorrow’s cabinet meeting, but it is reportedly set to include protection of workers’ rights and environmental standards, the aim of these being to try and persuade some Labour MPs to support PM May’s Brexit plan.
However the arithmetic still remains challenging, with several MPs having already expressed their scepticism over the plans. Sterling has continued to suffer from Brexit uncertainty with GBP:USD having fallen to a low of $1.2721 on Friday, its lowest level since January.
On one final point, note that European Parliamentary elections are set to be held in the UK this week (23 May), with polls continuing to point to a poor showing for the Tories, with the latest poll (Opinium), showing the Tories coming fourth, with just 12%, while the Brexit party was polling at 34%.
Government sources have indicated that there will be a further vote in the Commons on Brexit early next month. Specifically, this will be in the form of the Withdrawal Agreement Bill (the piece of legislation that will implement the EU Withdrawal Agreement), with the intention to introduce it to parliament in the week of 3 June.
A second reading and a vote are planned the following week. This will take place irrespective of whether or not the Tories and Labour enjoy any success in their cross-party talks. Of course, the Commons arithmetic remains difficult for the government with the previous ‘meaningful vote’ on the Withdrawal Agreement on failing by 58 votes on 29 March.
Friday 9 May
It is being reported that PM May plans to have a fourth shot at getting Parliament to back a Brexit deal, with plans to take the EU Withdrawal Agreement legislation to Parliament within the next two weeks.
The PM is doing so to try and stave off the risk new MEPs would actually have to take their seats following European Parliamentary elections (in the UK) on 23 May and as she fights for her own political survival for a time longer.
The PM looks to be pinning her hopes on reaching a deal with Labour, but almost all reports from these cross-party talks imply that they are getting nowhere fast amidst speculation that Labour will pull the plug any day now, bar a sudden and sizeable concession from the Conservative side of the negotiating table.
In terms of PM May’s position, the meeting of the 1922 Committee of backbench MPs held yesterday is reported as having been a gloomy and very frustrated one, with the PM having not yet laid out her plans to stand aside.
However she has promised to meet the executive of the 1922 Committee next week to discuss a timetable for her departure. Even so, Mrs May’s spokesman said yesterday that she “is here to deliver Brexit in phase one and then she will make way for phase two” so, depending on the passage of Brexit legislation, those frustrations amongst many on the 1922 Committee could persist a while longer.
Tuesday 8 May
The Government held three hours of talks with the Labour Party yesterday, but the opposition claimed that the Conservatives’ proposals on a customs compromise was ‘a million miles away’ from an acceptable proposal.
That said, both sides agreed to meet again. Meanwhile the pressure on Theresa May to step down early continues to mount, with the PM urged by 1922 Committee Chairman Sir Graham Brady to set out a timetable for her departure.
However media reports suggest that Mrs May is planning to announce she will step down in mid-July. Also defacto Deputy PM David Lidington conceded yesterday that the UK would have to participate in elections to the European Parliament on 23 May.
Thursday 11 April
Last night saw the EU offer PM Theresa May a longer extension than she initially requested. After lengthy discussions that went on into the early hours the EU finally offered the UK a new Article 50 extension that moves the Brexit date to 31 October 2019.
The EU itself was split on the length of the extension, with France pushing for a harder line and a shorter extension. In terms of the path from here, PM May will return to the UK today and attempt to sell the longer extension to her Cabinet.
Notably it is likely to face some opposition given that the October exit date now means that the UK will have to take part in European Parliamentary elections unless there is a miraculous turn in events and the UK is able to pass PM May’s Withdrawal Agreement - in such an event the UK would be permitted to leave earlier than 31 October.
Talks between the government and the Labour party are also set
to continue today, but whilst the government has described them as being constructive, Labour continues to accuse the government of being unwilling to move on red lines such as a permanent customs union.
Wednesday 10 April
Yesterday MPs voted 420 to 110 to back the Prime Minister’s proposals to extend the UK’s departure from the EU from 12 April to 30 June. But in a blow to the Prime Minister, 97 of the 110 MPs who opposed the “Brextension” were Eurosceptic Tories and a further 10 consisted of the government’s confidence and supply partners the DUP.
Nevertheless, parliament’s approval means that the Prime Minister will put forward her case as originally planned to EU27 leaders at 5:30pm London time tonight. Last night also saw the draft conclusions for this evening’s emergency Brexit Summit leaked to the media.
Notably, the document does not contain an explicit end date for any extension but rather states that it should be “no longer than [XX. XX. XXXX].” This comes amid reports that European capitals are divided on whether to extend Article 50 to the end of 2019 or to March 2020, with EU27 leaders set to make a firm decision tonight.
But the draft also offers an element of flexibility that would allow the UK to leave the EU earlier “if the Withdrawal Agreement is ratified by both parties before this date”, in which case Brexit would “take place on the first day of the following month”.
Overall it remains to be seen what the precise terms and length of any extension that will be offered by the EU27, but it looks almost certain to be longer than that sought by the Prime Minister.
Tuesday 9 April
Conservative ministers will meet their Labour equivalents today to try and break the Brexit impasse. It is understood that the PM has agreed to take up various EU employment and environmental protection laws after the UK leaves, but is not committing to remaining in a customs union.
Mrs May is due to have talks with both Angela Merkel and Emmanuel Macron today ahead of the emergency EU Summit tomorrow evening. The UK’s official request at the end of last week was for an extension to membership until 30 June.
This is largely thought to be unrealistic, with the EU more likely to make an offer for a longer delay to departure, and on the condition that the UK fights the European parliamentary elections in late May and that Britain agrees not to be obstructive within the EU during its prolonged membership.
While we are of the view that the EU will grant an extension, we should point out that the UK’s default path (i.e. if nothing happens), is that it leaves without a deal on Friday.
Monday 8 April
The weekend’s Brexit news flow has actually been relatively light on fundamental game changing news despite the UK’s current 12 April exit date fast approaching. In terms of events in the week ahead, there remains a high degree of uncertainty.
First, it remains to be seen how talks between the government and Labour on the way forward progress, with Friday seeing reports from Labour claiming that the government was offering no real changes in negotiations.
There is some talk that PM Theresa May could meet Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn later today in an attempt to kick start negotiations and reach some form of agreement which she could take to the EU summit on Wednesday to support her request for another Article 50 extension. But these discussions have yet to be formally agreed.
Should an agreement between the two be reached there is a suggestion that further parliamentary votes would be held tomorrow ahead of the Summit, but again at present there is nothing confirmed.
Second, Wednesday will see the EU hold an emergency summit, the purpose of which will be to decide on whether to grant the UK another Article 50 extension.
On Friday PM May requested an extension to the 30 June, however EU leaders have various opinions on another extension. EU President Donald Tusk has suggested a ‘flexible’ 1-year extension to April 2020, whereby the UK could exit earlier if the Withdrawal Agreement were to be ratified by the British Parliament before then.
But there are also those among the EU taking a much harder line such as French President Macron, which suggests the process of agreeing another extension this Wednesday might not be so straight forward.
Friday 5 April
News reports suggest that EU Council President Donald Tusk will offer the UK an Article 50 extension of up to a year at the emergency EU Summit on Wednesday next week. This follows reports that (perhaps unsurprisingly) the discussions between Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn are unlikely to break the impasse.
Indeed Attorney General Geoffrey Cox remarked yesterday that if the talks failed, any delay would ‘likely to be a long one’. In terms of the wider political scene, yesterday’s by-election in Newport West resulted in Labour holding the seat with a reduced majority of 1,951.
This reduces the Tories’ effective majority in Parliament to 5.
Thursday 4 April
There were two themes to Brexit developments yesterday. Firstly, the House of Commons approved legislation (by 313 votes to 312!) which would force Prime Minister Theresa May to seek a Brexit delay to prevent a disorderly no-deal outcome on 12 April.
The legislation still needs to pass the House of Lords (debate starts later this morning) and be signed into law. Even then, the UK would still be required to take action to actually avert a no-deal outcome, with this still the ‘default’ outcome.
As such, whilst the vote moves to put in law the will of the House, it still does not avert no deal. It will though allow the UK to argue in talks with Brussels that Parliament can at least agree that a Brexit delay/aversion of no deal is something UK Parliament wants to avoid.
Yesterday we also saw talks take place between PM May and Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn to try and find a way forward on the shape of future arrangement for UK-EU relations, which might be able to carry the will of the House and therefore form the basis of a further Brexit extension request to be taken to the EU Summit on 10 April.
The mood at these talks looks to have been a positive one, but the Labour leader also said that the PM had not yet moved enough. Talks will continue today whilst there look to be continuing internal discussions within the Labour party over whether to demand another (confirmatory) referendum.
In the Tory ranks, there continue to be significant grumblings over the discussions taking place with Labour. We saw two government resignations yesterday and there continue to be reports that more could follow, depending on the direction talks move in.
Sterling struggled for momentum early in the day yesterday (click here for latest rates) following the poor UK services PMI, but recovered those losses through the day with the pound at $1.3186 at the time of writing.
Wednesday 3 April
After a marathon seven-hour Cabinet meeting, the Prime Minister announced that the UK would seek a further extension of Article 50 at next week’s emergency Brexit summit.
In order to devise a “way forward” for the EU27 (upon which an extension would be conditional), she reached out to Leader of the Opposition, Jeremy Corbyn, to try to forge a new parliamentary consensus.
But if the two fail to reach an agreement, the Prime Minister has pledged to hold a “run-off” vote in the House of Commons between her agreed deal and alternative options. She has pledged to honour the result of this X Factor-style showdown, providing that Mr Corbyn makes the same commitment.
The two leaders are set to meet today, but we are sceptical whether there is sufficient time for a change in Brexit strategy given the proximity to next week’s EU Summit. At the same time it serves to further sow further division with the eurosceptic wing of the Tory party, not least after Downing Street confirmed it would lay a parliamentary order on 11 April to make preparations for European Parliament elections but pointed out that the poll could be cancelled at any date up until 22 May.
Further opposition has come from her confidence and supply partners, the DUP, who said the decision was “little surprise” given her “lamentable” handling of the Brexit negotiations. Note also that Sir Oliver Letwin MP is expected to put forward a motion this afternoon that is designed to clear a path for a bill sponsored by Yvette Cooper MP which is designed to take a no-deal Brexit off the table.
Overall markets have taken last night’s announcement positively, its vagaries notwithstanding, with cable rising around a cent overnight to $1.3146 currently.
Tuesday 2 April
Last night saw the House of Commons hold another round of indicative votes on four alternative Brexit options, once again all failed to win a majority. The one option that came closest to securing a majority was Ken Clarke’s customs union proposal, which lost by three votes (276-273).
Nick Bole’s proposal of Common Market 2.0 (customs union + single market) lost by 21 votes (282-261). The remaining indicative votes were for a public vote on any Brexit deal (defeated 292-280) and motion G, which aimed to prevent the UK leaving without a deal (defeated 292-191).
Last night also saw Nick Boles quit as a Tory MP following the defeat of his Common Market 2.0 proposal, he will now sit as an ‘independent progressive conservative’. Importantly, this narrows the government’s majority to just 7, a majority which is set to be whittled down further to just 6 following the Newport West by-election this Thursday.
Additionally there are also some question marks over Dominic Grieve’s position, following his loss in a local party confidence vote on Friday and talk of possible de-selection, a prospect which would cut the Tory majority again.
In short the differences over Brexit are ever deepening the splits in the Tory party. Looking forward there is set to be an extended cabinet meeting today, where there is talk that some ministers will urge the PM to consider an early general election in order to try and break the deadlock. We would reiterate once more that we fail to see how this would help the current situation.
Beyond that a third round of indicative votes is set to be held this Wednesday, which could be followed by a fourth vote on PM May’s deal in a ‘play-off’ against any option that might win on Wednesday. However a fourth vote is yet to be confirmed.
Monday 1 April
Today MPs will seek to whittle down the number of alternatives to the Prime Minister’s Brexit deal through a second round of “indicative votes”. Eight motions have been proposed and will be debated sometime between 3:30pm and 6:00pm (at the latest), after which the Speaker of the House of Commons will select which will be put to a vote at 8:00pm.
Results are expected around 10:00pm, but the leading option appears to be the customs union mooted by Ken Clarke MP which (after a recount) was defeated by just six votes in the first round last week. Reports suggest that if any single proposal is able to command a majority, MPs will then seek to turn this non-binding display of parliamentary will into a legally-binding commitment on the government.
Having sensed that a softer Brexit is now in the works, some 170 Eurosceptic MPs (including 10 cabinet ministers) wrote to the Prime Minister at the weekend demanding a departure from the EU with or without a deal. There are also mumblings that the Prime Minister is considering whether to bring back the Withdrawal Agreement to the Commons, with Thursday apparently pencilled in, though other days have been mentioned.
There is also talk that May’s deal could be pitched in a run-off against any winner from tonight’s indicative votes. Note, however, that its confidence and supply partners the DUP still appears unwilling to support it, with Sammy Wilson MP saying that the party would not vote for it even if it was brought to the Commons a "a thousand times”.
Against this chaotic backdrop, it is perhaps unsurprising that the Sunday papers were full of speculation about a snap general election. The opposition Labour party can smell blood, with Shadow Foreign Secretary Emily Thornberry warning it now looked likely that Labour would put down another vote of no confidence in the government to get a general election.
But while the likelihood of another general election has risen over recent months, how it would solve the current deadlock in Westminster is unclear.
Browse articles in